60 Funniest Ways to Respond to "Guess Who?" Messages

There’s something delightfully playful about a message that simply says, “Guess who?” It’s an invitation to banter, to show off your humor, and sometimes, to let your wild imagination roam. While some may opt for a straightforward guess, others see this as a prime opportunity to make the conversation entertaining.

From mythical creatures and famous icons to outlandish characters, the possibilities are endless. Here, we’ll dive into 60 of the funniest responses to throw back when someone asks, “Guess who?” Each response is crafted to amuse and keep the conversation light and enjoyable.

Let’s get into it!

Table of Contents

List of Funny Responses to “Guess Who”

Here are 60 funny ways to respond to “Guess who?” messages:

Is it Santa Claus?
Batman, is that you?
My long-lost twin!
The pizza delivery guy?
An alien from outer space?
The ghost of Christmas past?
Is it the Tooth Fairy?
Bigfoot, finally!
My imaginary friend?
The Easter Bunny?
The Queen of England?
Sherlock Holmes, I presume?
A time traveler from the future?
The President of Mars?
My conscience?
Elvis Presley?
Harry Potter?
A genie from a lamp?
Dr. Who?
My evil twin?
A leprechaun?
Is it Waldo?
The Loch Ness Monster?
A ninja in disguise?
My guardian angel?
Zeus, king of the gods?
The invisible man?
Is it Rumpelstiltskin?
My alter ego?
Sherlock Holmes?
A Jedi Knight?
The Tooth Fairy?
An undercover superhero?
A unicorn in disguise?
The real Slim Shady?
A ghostbuster?
My fairy godmother?
A Hogwarts professor?
A pirate from the Caribbean?
The Wizard of Oz?
An undercover cop?
A minion from Despicable Me?
The cat who got the cream?
My future self?
A secret agent?
The mad hatter?
A talking parrot?
A hologram?
A pirate?
The Sandman?
A super spy?
The Stig from Top Gear?
An alien invader?
A fortune teller?
An escape artist?
A secret admirer?
The Cookie Monster?
A mythical creature?
The Phantom of the Opera?
A superhero in disguise?

1. Is it Santa Claus?

Nothing says “Guess who?” like envisioning a visit from the jolly man himself. This response is bound to start things off with a laugh, especially around the holidays.

Example: “Is it Santa Claus? If so, I promise I’ve been good this year—mostly!”
Example: “Wait, Santa? Should I leave out milk and cookies, or are you off-duty?”
Example: “Santa, is that you? Just double-checking my wish list—did you get it?”

2. Batman, is that you?

Bringing up Batman instantly adds a touch of mystery, perfect for keeping the “Guess who?” conversation lively and imaginative.

Example: “Batman, is that you? Should I be worried, or are we safe tonight?”
Example: “Did Gotham finally take a break, or are you just out on patrol?”
Example: “Batman? I knew my city needed a hero, but didn’t expect it would be you!”

3. My long-lost twin!

Imagining your mysterious “guess who” sender as your twin is an amusing way to keep them guessing and add a little playfulness.

Example: “My long-lost twin! Finally, we’re reunited! Have you been on some wild adventures?”
Example: “Twin, where have you been all my life? We have so much to catch up on!”
Example: “Lost twin? If we’re identical, are you as charming as I am?”

4. The pizza delivery guy?

This response is simple but effective—everyone loves pizza, and it’ll get a laugh while keeping the mood light.

Example: “The pizza delivery guy? Because if you are, I’m ready with the tip!”
Example: “Wait, pizza? Did you bring extra cheese?”
Example: “Pizza delivery? You’re definitely my favorite person today!”

5. An alien from outer space?

Getting otherworldly is a funny way to keep the conversation going, especially if you want to give an out-of-the-box answer.

Example: “An alien from outer space? Finally! Take me to your leader.”
Example: “Outer space visitor? Guess I should brush up on my alien languages!”
Example: “Alien? Do you come in peace, or is this an invasion?”

6. The ghost of Christmas past?

This response is a playful nod to the classic holiday tale and perfect for adding a bit of spooky fun.

Example: “The ghost of Christmas past? Here to remind me of all my holiday shopping I haven’t done yet?”
Example: “Oh no, am I supposed to be learning a life lesson right now?”
Example: “The ghost of Christmas past! Tell me, did I make the naughty or nice list?”

7. Is it the Tooth Fairy?

This brings back a bit of childhood nostalgia, imagining the mysterious sender as a magical figure from our youth.

Example: “The Tooth Fairy? Just checking—are you still paying good money for teeth?”
Example: “Wait, is it the Tooth Fairy? Should I start wiggling a tooth for extra cash?”
Example: “Tooth Fairy, if that’s you, I hope you’re ready to upgrade the rates!”

8. Bigfoot, finally!

A hilarious option for a “Guess who?” response, playing along like you’ve finally found the infamous cryptid.

Example: “Bigfoot? Wait, I thought you were just a myth!”
Example: “Bigfoot, we finally meet! Can I take a selfie as proof?”
Example: “The legendary Bigfoot! Guess the mystery is solved!”

9. My imaginary friend?

A lighthearted way to respond, pretending they’re the friend you made up in your childhood.

Example: “My imaginary friend! I knew you’d come back to visit eventually!”
Example: “Imaginary friend? We have so much catching up to do since kindergarten!”
Example: “Hey, imaginary friend, long time no see! Still remember our secret handshake?”

10. The Easter Bunny?

A fun and festive guess, especially around spring, that keeps things playful and surprising.

Example: “The Easter Bunny? Please say you brought chocolate eggs!”
Example: “Wait, is it Easter Bunny season already? Guess I should get my basket ready!”
Example: “The Easter Bunny? I promise I’ve been good all year for those eggs!”

11. The Queen of England?

For a royal touch, imagining the sender as royalty adds elegance and humor.

Example: “The Queen of England? An absolute honor, Your Majesty!”
Example: “Her Majesty herself? What brings you to my humble phone?”
Example: “Queen of England! Just give me a minute to roll out the red carpet.”

12. Sherlock Holmes, I presume?

This clever response gives a nod to the iconic detective, adding a bit of mystery.

Example: “Sherlock Holmes? Solving any mysteries, or is this just a casual drop-in?”
Example: “Sherlock! Should I grab my detective hat and join you on a case?”
Example: “The one and only Sherlock Holmes! I have a few cases that need solving.”

13. A time traveler from the future?

For a futuristic twist, this response is perfect if you want to keep things out-of-this-world.

Example: “Time traveler? Quick, tell me the winning lottery numbers!”
Example: “Are you here to warn me about something, oh wise time traveler?”
Example: “Time traveler from the future! So, how does 2025 look?”

14. The President of Mars?

An interplanetary twist that’s sure to keep the “Guess who?” conversation fun and lighthearted.

Example: “The President of Mars? I’ve got some questions about space tourism!”
Example: “Mars President! What’s the weather like on the red planet these days?”
Example: “The President of Mars! Does Earth have your vote?”

15. My conscience?

This introspective answer brings a bit of humor, as if your conscience is suddenly texting you.

Example: “My conscience? Just checking—are we okay with my latest life decisions?”
Example: “Conscience, is that you? Tell me I’m doing a good job!”
Example: “My conscience! If this is about my last pizza binge, I can explain!”

16. Elvis Presley?

A throwback to the King of Rock and Roll, imagining Elvis on the other end brings some nostalgic humor.

Example: “Elvis? You’re back! Do you still have the blue suede shoes?”
Example: “The King himself! Guess you couldn’t resist texting from Graceland.”
Example: “Elvis! Is this the comeback we’ve all been waiting for?”

17. Harry Potter?

For a magical twist, thinking of the sender as the famous wizard adds whimsy to the conversation.

Example: “Harry Potter? You here to teach me some spells?”
Example: “Harry! Did you finally find my Hogwarts letter?”
Example: “The Chosen One! Please say you brought your wand!”

18. A genie from a lamp?

Pretending the sender is a magical genie ready to grant wishes is a surefire way to keep things lively.

Example: “A genie? Great! I’ve got my three wishes ready!”
Example: “Genie! First wish: Let’s skip Monday mornings forever.”
Example: “My very own genie! Can we start with a pizza?”

19. Dr. Who?

For fans of the famous time-traveling doctor, this response adds a sci-fi flair.

Example: “Dr. Who! Does this mean we’re going on an adventure through time?”
Example: “Doctor! I’ve been waiting for my TARDIS ride!”
Example: “The one and only Doctor! Just tell me we’re saving the world together.”

20. My evil twin?

A little mischievous, imagining an evil twin adds a funny twist to the guessing game.

Example: “My evil twin! What schemes have you been up to this time?”
Example: “Evil twin alert! Let’s swap places and confuse everyone.”
Example: “My evil twin! Guess we’re double trouble now.”

21. A leprechaun? Here to bring me a pot of gold, perhaps?

Pretending the sender is a leprechaun is both whimsical and humorous, adding a bit of Irish luck to the conversation.

Example: “A leprechaun? Perfect timing—I could use a pot of gold right about now!”
Example: “A leprechaun! Does this mean I get three wishes, or just one pot of gold?”
Example: “A leprechaun! Just curious, do you grant wishes, or is it only about rainbows and gold?”

22. Is it Waldo? I’ve been looking for you everywhere!

Channeling the classic “Where’s Waldo?” books, this guess is a playful way to imply you’ve been searching for them.

Example: “Is it Waldo? Took me long enough to spot you!”
Example: “Waldo! I feel like I’ve been searching for you forever.”
Example: “Waldo, is that you? No wonder it’s been so hard to find you!”

23. The Loch Ness Monster? Making a rare appearance, are we?

The Loch Ness Monster is a mythical creature that rarely “shows up,” making it a funny choice for a mysterious message.

Example: “The Loch Ness Monster? Wow, didn’t expect a sighting today!”
Example: “Loch Ness Monster! Just one quick selfie for proof, please.”
Example: “The Loch Ness Monster! I thought you only appeared in blurry photos.”

24. A ninja in disguise? Sneaky, aren’t we?

This response works well if the sender has been “silent” for a while, keeping things playful and adding a mysterious touch.

Example: “A ninja in disguise? So, this is why I haven’t heard from you!”
Example: “Ninja mode activated, I see. Keeping those stealth skills sharp?”
Example: “A ninja in disguise! I’ll try not to blow your cover.”

25. My guardian angel? Here to save me from something?

A sweet yet humorous guess, imagining the sender as a guardian angel brings an amusing, caring twist.

Example: “My guardian angel! Here to save me from my Monday blues?”
Example: “Guardian angel alert! Do you have any wisdom to share today?”
Example: “My guardian angel! Guess I must be doing something right.”

26. Zeus, king of the gods? Bringing thunder and lightning my way?

Pretending Zeus is on the other end is a powerful and dramatic guess, perfect for some mythological flair.

Example: “Zeus! Should I expect a thunderstorm, or are you just checking in?”
Example: “The king of the gods! Guess I’m in the presence of greatness.”
Example: “Zeus! Here to share some ancient wisdom or just stir up some drama?”

27. The invisible man? I can’t see you, but I know you’re there!

Referencing “The Invisible Man” adds mystery and a bit of suspense, keeping the guessing game playful.

Example: “The Invisible Man! I had a feeling you were lurking around.”
Example: “Invisible Man, is that you? I always knew you’d find me eventually.”
Example: “The Invisible Man! Are you just hiding, or is this a new superpower?”

28. Is it Rumpelstiltskin? Ready to make some magical deals?

This fairy-tale-inspired guess is a unique twist, especially if the sender has a sense of mystery.

Example: “Rumpelstiltskin? Just checking—what’s the price for spinning straw into gold these days?”
Example: “Is it Rumpelstiltskin? I didn’t agree to any deals… did I?”
Example: “Rumpelstiltskin! Hope you’re not here to collect on any old promises.”

29. My alter ego? Are we about to cause some mischief?

Suggesting they’re your alter ego adds a bit of humor and suggests a mischievous connection between you two.

Example: “My alter ego! Ready to stir up some harmless trouble?”
Example: “Alter ego, is that you? Guess that means double the fun.”
Example: “My alter ego! Let’s keep our mischief under wraps.”

30. Sherlock Holmes? Are we solving a mystery today?

Invoking Sherlock Holmes gives a nod to the classic detective character, adding a sense of adventure to the chat.

Example: “Sherlock Holmes! Are we cracking a case, or just catching up?”
Example: “Sherlock! I knew you’d find the clues to reach me.”
Example: “The great detective! Hope you brought your magnifying glass.”

31. A Jedi Knight? May the Force be with you!

This response brings Star Wars energy, perfect for any sci-fi fan who wants to keep the conversation entertaining.

Example: “A Jedi Knight! Just let me know if we’re training with lightsabers.”
Example: “Jedi Knight, is that you? May the Force be strong with us today!”
Example: “The Force brought us together, I see. Jedi business, perhaps?”

32. The Tooth Fairy? Here for more teeth?

Referencing the Tooth Fairy gives a nostalgic twist and adds a playful vibe to the guessing game.

Example: “The Tooth Fairy! Do you pay in cash or just glitter?”
Example: “Tooth Fairy, you’re back! Didn’t know I had any teeth left to give!”
Example: “The Tooth Fairy! Are you running low on supply these days?”

33. An undercover superhero? Keeping your identity a secret, I see!

Pretending they’re a superhero in disguise adds a fun, dramatic twist, especially if they’re keeping things mysterious.

Example: “Undercover superhero! Do I get to know your superpower?”
Example: “A superhero! I knew I felt a heroic presence nearby.”
Example: “Undercover superhero! I’ll keep your identity safe—promise.”

34. A unicorn in disguise? Magical and mysterious, just like you!

Unicorns add a sense of fantasy, making this guess fun and lighthearted for any mystery texter.

Example: “A unicorn! Just my luck to meet a magical creature.”
Example: “Unicorn in disguise? Should I expect sparkles and rainbows?”
Example: “The magical unicorn! I knew you’d find me one day.”

35. The real Slim Shady? Will the real one please stand up?

Referencing the famous line adds a pop culture twist, especially if they’re keeping their identity hidden.

Example: “Slim Shady! Finally, the real one has shown up!”
Example: “The real Slim Shady? Should I be ready to rap?”
Example: “Slim Shady! Guess it’s my lucky day!”

36. A ghostbuster? Who you gonna call—me, I guess!

If you suspect a ghostly vibe from your mysterious texter, this is a funny way to respond, inspired by the famous movie.

Example: “A ghostbuster! Hope you’re here to protect me from any spooky visitors!”
Example: “Who you gonna call? Ghostbusters, or just me today?”
Example: “Ghostbuster alert! Do I need to worry about any haunted places nearby?”

37. My fairy godmother? Granting me a wish, are you?

Playing along as though they’re your fairy godmother is a sweet and funny twist, hinting they’ve arrived to make your day magical.

Example: “My fairy godmother! Just what I needed—one wish, please!”
Example: “Fairy godmother, you’re here! I’ve been waiting for some magic.”
Example: “Fairy godmother alert! Shall we start with a pumpkin carriage?”

38. A Hogwarts professor? Ready to teach me some spells?

This guess is perfect for Harry Potter fans who would enjoy the idea of a mysterious Hogwarts professor messaging them.

Example: “A Hogwarts professor! Which spell are we learning today?”
Example: “Professor, it’s an honor! Do I get extra credit?”
Example: “A Hogwarts professor! Hope you’re here to teach some magic tricks.”

39. A pirate from the Caribbean? Arrr, ready for some treasure hunting?

Imagining your texter as a pirate brings a playful, adventurous vibe, especially if they’re being mysterious.

Example: “A pirate! Did you bring a treasure map, or just a good story?”
Example: “Arrr, a pirate from the Caribbean! Guess we’re going on an adventure.”
Example: “Pirate alert! Where’s the treasure, Captain?”

40. The Wizard of Oz? Here to whisk me off to the Emerald City?

Referencing the Wizard of Oz gives a whimsical twist, perfect for keeping things lighthearted and fun.

Example: “The Wizard of Oz! Hope you’re bringing some ruby slippers for me.”
Example: “Wizard of Oz? Guess I’m off to the Emerald City!”
Example: “Are we following the yellow brick road, Wizard?”

41. An undercover cop? Am I in some kind of secret mission?

This one’s a funny twist, as it implies you’re being recruited for a “top-secret” mission without even knowing it.

Example: “An undercover cop! Do I need to start speaking in code?”
Example: “Undercover agent? Guess I should be on my best behavior!”
Example: “Undercover cop! Is this a stakeout or just a friendly chat?”

42. A minion from Despicable Me? Bringing some mischief, I assume?

If you’re in the mood for something silly, guessing they’re a minion from Despicable Me is sure to add some laughs.

Example: “A minion! I hope you’re not causing too much trouble today.”
Example: “Minion, is that you? Hope you brought some bananas!”
Example: “Despicable Me vibes! I’ll join in on the mischief if you are.”

43. The cat who got the cream? Feeling smug today, are we?

This response is playful and suggests the sender might be feeling a bit sneaky or sly, like a satisfied cat.

Example: “The cat who got the cream! What’s got you so smug?”
Example: “Cat with the cream, huh? Must’ve gotten away with something good.”
Example: “So, the cat’s got the cream today! Spill the secret.”

44. My future self? Are you here to give me some advice?

If the sender seems to know you well, pretending they’re your future self is a fun way to keep them guessing.

Example: “Future me! Tell me, did I make it big?”
Example: “My future self! What do I need to know about tomorrow?”
Example: “Future me! Guess you came back to warn me about something?”

45. A secret agent? Working undercover, are we?

If they’re keeping their identity hidden, this guess keeps things thrilling by imagining them as a covert operative.

Example: “Secret agent! Hope you’re not giving away any confidential info.”
Example: “An undercover mission, I see. What’s our code word?”
Example: “Secret agent vibes! Do I get a code name, too?”

46. The Mad Hatter? Here to throw a tea party, perhaps?

Referencing the Mad Hatter from Alice in Wonderland adds an eccentric and playful twist, perfect for keeping it light.

Example: “The Mad Hatter! Guess that means it’s time for a tea party!”
Example: “Mad Hatter! Hope you brought plenty of tea and nonsense.”
Example: “The Mad Hatter! When’s the next un-birthday party?”

47. A talking parrot? Ready to repeat everything I say?

Pretending they’re a talking parrot gives a quirky response that’s bound to make them chuckle.

Example: “A talking parrot! Just don’t repeat anything embarrassing.”
Example: “Parrot alert! Guess I’ll keep my words short and sweet.”
Example: “A parrot! Feel free to squawk at your leisure.”

48. A hologram? Are you even real?

This is a funny way to question if they’re actually there, giving a futuristic twist to your guess.

Example: “A hologram? Guess I’ll never know if you’re real or not.”
Example: “Hologram! Just checking—can you see me too?”
Example: “A hologram? What a high-tech surprise!”

49. A pirate? Arrr, ready to set sail?

Another pirate response, but this one’s even more general, for when you’re just in the mood for a fun adventure.

Example: “Pirate alert! Hope you’re ready for a sea-faring tale.”
Example: “Arrr, a pirate! Shall we set sail for uncharted waters?”
Example: “A pirate, eh? Guess I better find my sea legs.”

50. The Sandman? Here to bring me some good dreams?

Referencing the Sandman is a soothing and imaginative response, perfect if it’s late and you’re winding down.

Example: “The Sandman! Just what I needed for a good night’s sleep.”
Example: “Sandman! Hope you brought some sweet dreams along.”
Example: “The Sandman! Guess it’s time to call it a night.”

51. A super spy? Who sent you?

Implying they’re a super spy adds a dramatic twist and a dash of excitement, making them feel like they’re on a mission.

Example: “A super spy! Should I be worried about secret intel?”
Example: “Super spy, is that you? Guess my secrets are safe no more.”
Example: “So, you’re the super spy! Do I need to go undercover?”

52. The Stig from Top Gear? Here to show off some speed?

Referencing Top Gear adds a fun and unexpected twist, especially if they’re known for being quick or stealthy.

Example: “The Stig! What’s the top speed you’re reaching today?”
Example: “The Stig! Should I be worried about a racing challenge?”
Example: “Top Gear’s Stig! I’ll bet you’re here to leave me in the dust.”

53. An alien invader? Are you here in peace?

Adding a sci-fi twist by calling them an alien is a playful way to keep things lighthearted and mysterious.

Example: “An alien invader! Do I need to phone home?”
Example: “Alien invasion! Guess it’s time for a close encounter.”
Example: “Alien! Please tell me you’re a friendly visitor.”

54. A fortune teller? Ready to reveal my future?

Pretending they’re a fortune teller keeps the mystery alive, especially if they seem to know a lot about you.

Example: “Fortune teller! Can you tell me my fortune for today?”
Example: “A fortune teller! Hope you have some good news in that crystal ball.”
Example: “Fortune teller! Spill the secrets of my future.”

55. An escape artist? Are you planning a great escape?

Pretending they’re an escape artist gives a playful twist, like they’re always trying to slip away or stay elusive.

Example: “An escape artist! Guess I’ll have to keep an eye on you.”
Example: “Escape artist vibes! So, what’s your latest daring escape?”
Example: “An escape artist! Just don’t vanish before I figure out who you are!”

56. A secret admirer? Have you been admiring from afar?

This one is both funny and flattering, adding a hint of mystery and charm to the guessing game.

Example: “A secret admirer! How mysterious—you’ve caught my attention.”
Example: “Secret admirer alert! Guess I’ll need to be on the lookout for clues.”
Example: “My secret admirer! Guess the mystery deepens even more!”

57. The Cookie Monster? Bringing me cookies, I hope?

Imagining your texter as the lovable Cookie Monster brings a lighthearted vibe, especially if they’re a foodie or known for their sweet tooth.

Example: “Cookie Monster! Hope you’ve got some chocolate chip cookies ready.”
Example: “The Cookie Monster! Please tell me you’re here with treats.”
Example: “Cookie Monster vibes! Guess I’m in for a delicious surprise.”

58. A mythical creature? I always knew magic was real!

If they’re keeping things mysterious, pretending they’re a mythical creature gives it a magical, fun twist.

Example: “A mythical creature! So, magic does exist!”
Example: “Mythical creature, huh? Guess I’m talking to a legend.”
Example: “A mythical friend! You must be here to share some enchanted stories.”

59. The Phantom of the Opera? Ready for a grand entrance?

Referring to the Phantom adds a dramatic and mysterious flair, especially if your texter has an air of intrigue.

Example: “The Phantom of the Opera! Guess I should expect some grand theatrics.”
Example: “Phantom vibes! Are you lurking in the shadows somewhere?”
Example: “The Phantom himself! Hope you’ve brought some music with you.”

60. A superhero in disguise? Here to save the day?

Wrapping up the list with a superhero guess adds an epic twist, making them feel like they’re here for a big reveal.

Example: “A superhero in disguise! Guess I’m in safe hands.”
Example: “Superhero vibes! Are you here to save the day or just make me laugh?”
Example: “A superhero, huh? So, do I get to see your superpowers now?”

Conclusion

When it comes to responding to a “Guess who?” text, creativity can take a conversation from ordinary to extraordinary. Each of these funny, imaginative responses is designed to add humor and keep things playful. Whether you go for the mysterious “Phantom of the Opera” or the whimsical “fairy godmother,” you’ll bring a smile to the other person’s face and keep them guessing.

The best part? These responses can be tailored to suit any personality and make light of the guessing game, creating memorable exchanges that break the ice or just add a bit of fun to the day.

Have fun with these, and remember—sometimes, the best response to a “Guess who?” message is simply to let your imagination run wild.